Common Grounds for Will Contests in Georgia

Family disagreements around inheritance can quickly snowball into legal disputes, especially when someone questions the validity of a loved one’s will. These situations can be difficult and emotional, often mixing grief with tension. Will contests are formal objections raised against the legitimacy of a will, and they usually happen when someone feels the document doesn’t reflect the true wishes of the person who passed away.


In Georgia, the laws around wills are clear, but that doesn’t stop conflicts from happening. Whether it’s because of mental capacity issues, external pressure, or a will that wasn’t signed correctly, several situations could give someone legal ground to challenge it. Knowing the common reasons for these challenges helps people write better estate plans and gives families the clarity they need during tough times.


Understanding Will Contests in Georgia


A will contest is a legal challenge where someone questions the validity of a last will and testament. That might mean claiming the person who made the will wasn’t mentally capable, that someone else manipulated them, or that the document itself isn’t legitimate. These disputes often come from children, spouses, or other close relatives who believe the will doesn’t reflect what their loved one wanted or what’s fair.


Georgia law outlines specific reasons that make a will invalid, and only certain people, usually those named in or affected by the will, have legal standing to contest it. Even when estate planning seems airtight, the potential for family conflict or misunderstanding is always there. That’s why understanding your legal rights and responsibilities matters. These cases can become long and stressful, especially when emotions are high, so it helps to be clear upfront about what makes a will challenge stick.


For example, if someone leaves their entire estate to one beneficiary and excludes close family members without explanation, those left out might believe something questionable happened. The legal system doesn’t automatically side with them, but they can move forward with a formal contest if they can back up their claims with evidence.


Lack Of Testamentary Capacity


One of the most common reasons for a will contest is lack of testamentary capacity. That means the person who made the will wasn’t of sound mind at the time they signed it. Georgia law requires that someone creating a will understands three basic things:


- What property they own

- Who their family members are

- How they want their property to be divided


If someone doesn’t grasp one or more of these areas, a court might rule that the will isn’t valid.


Common signs that someone may not have had capacity include significant memory loss, confusion about where they are or who their relatives are, or being easily manipulated. Dementia is one health-related issue that often comes up in conversations about capacity. While a diagnosis alone doesn’t prove someone lacked capacity, it can be part of the bigger picture.


Courts usually look at medical records, witness statements, and other evidence to reach a decision. Timing is important. Just because someone was confused one day doesn’t mean they were confused when the will was signed. That’s why it's smart to have witnesses, and sometimes even video recordings, when a will is being finalized. These small steps can help avoid problems later on.


Undue Influence


Undue influence happens when someone pressures or manipulates the person making the will to write it in their favor. This kind of influence has to seriously override the person’s free will. It’s not just persuasion. It's closer to control.


Here are a few warning signs that undue influence may be involved:


- The will dramatically favors one person, especially if the change came late in life

- The person making the will was isolated from family or friends

- Someone had control over finances, communication, or daily care

- There were major last-minute changes to the will that seem out of character


These cases often involve caregivers, relatives, or others in close contact with the person who wrote the will. The court will look for patterns of control, dependency, or manipulation. Emails, letters, text messages, and witness testimony can help show whether undue influence occurred. Like with lack of capacity, it’s not easy to prove, but when the right signs are there, the claim becomes a strong one.


Understanding these early signs helps families stay alert during the estate planning process and reduces the risk of future court battles.


Fraud And Forgery In Estate Documents


Fraud and forgery are serious reasons people contest wills in Georgia. Fraud means the person signing the will was misled, that someone lied or tricked them into signing something they didn’t truly understand. Forgery means the signature on the will isn’t real. In both situations, the intent behind the document isn’t genuine, which is a big problem when settling an estate.


Here are a couple of examples of how these issues can happen:


Someone might pretend to help an elderly person with their paperwork, but instead, they swap in a different will that gives them everything. Or a family member might forge a signature on a document and try to pass it off as valid. Either way, it creates legal battles that often drag out for months or even years.


The challenge is proving these claims. Courts need strong proof, like handwriting analysis or testimony from people who were there during the signing. The law doesn’t take accusations of fraud or forgery lightly, so it’s important for families to collect real evidence before moving forward.


Being alert during the estate planning process, double-checking documents, and relying on trusted witnesses can help avoid fraud and forgery to begin with. Once a forged or fraudulent will is in place, untangling the mess can turn into a lengthy court dispute no one saw coming.


Improper Execution Makes A Will Invalid


Wills must follow specific rules to be legal in Georgia. If those rules aren’t met, the will might get tossed out even if it reflects the true wishes of the person who died. That’s why execution errors are another common reason for will contests.


For a will to be properly executed in Georgia:


- The person making the will must sign it voluntarily

- It must be signed in front of two competent witnesses

- The witnesses must sign the will in the presence of the person making it


If one of those elements is missing or done incorrectly, the will could be challenged. You’d be surprised how small mistakes can cause big problems. Missing a witness signature or signing the will without them present can make the document invalid.


In some cases, people assume a handwritten will or digital note is good enough. But if it doesn’t meet the legal requirements, it might not hold up in court. That’s when estate litigation can come into play. Family members can question the process and push for a judge to throw out the document.


To avoid these issues, planning ahead helps a lot. Getting the right people involved, checking the legal steps during signing, and storing documents safely all make a big difference. Once someone passes, their loved ones need that certainty to keep things clear and fair.


How to Help Your Family Avoid a Will Contest Later


Avoiding a will contest often starts long before someone passes away. A solid estate plan makes it harder to raise valid questions after the fact. That means taking the time to understand the legal process, keeping records of discussions and changes, and making sure everything is done by the book.


Here are a few simple things that go a long way toward reducing fights over estates in Georgia:


- Use clear, easy-to-read terms in the will to avoid confusion

- Update estate plans after major life events like remarriage or the birth of a child

- Communicate with family about major decisions to prevent misunderstandings

- Keep a record of why changes were made to reduce suspicion later


When families are caught off guard, that’s when disputes usually begin. Simple communication and documentation can prevent major fallout. For example, one family in North Georgia avoided a long courtroom process because their father explained all changes to his will during frequent family meetings. He even had his attorney write letters to confirm key updates. Those small actions created a layer of trust that kept everything running smoothly after his death.


Working with someone who understands Georgia law can be the difference between a peaceful process and one filled with uncertainty. Wills should speak clearly, follow the law, and leave no room for guesswork later on. Estate plans are more than forms. They’re long-term tools that give your family confidence during some of life’s hardest transitions.


Planning ahead with clear estate documents can help prevent disputes among family members and ensure smooth transitions. If you're navigating the often complex waters of estate litigation, let McGinn Law guide you. We provide the insights you need to secure your family's future with thoughtful estate planning and management.


Blog

Capital Gains
29 November 2025
Questions about capital gains come up often in Estate Planning. Clients want to know: “If I pass my property to my children, will they have to pay capital gains tax?” It’s an important question, and the answer depends entirely on how and when that transfer happens. Understanding these distinctions can make a significant financial difference for your family. When Assets Gain Value, So Do Tax Considerations A Capital Gain is the profit realized when an asset, a home, land, or investment, is sold for more than its original purchase price. If you bought a property for $100,000 and sell it years later for $250,000, the $150,000 difference is your gain, and it’s taxable. That’s the basic version. But when the property isn’t sold, when it’s gifted or inherited , things work differently. Gifting During Life vs. Transferring at Death If you gift property during your lifetime , the person receiving it also inherits your original cost basis . That means when they sell it, they’ll owe taxes on any increase in value that occurred both before and after you gave it to them. For instance, if you purchased the property for $100,000 and it’s now worth $250,000, your recipient could face capital gains taxes on that $150,000 increase when they decide to sell. However, if that same property is transferred through your estate or a trust , the rules change in a way that often benefits your heirs. The Step-Up in Basis: A Powerful Adjustment When an asset passes through an Estate after the owner’s death, the tax basis , the value used to calculate gain or loss, is “stepped up” to the fair market value at the time of death. This reset can significantly reduce or even eliminate capital gains tax for your heirs. Let’s return to our example: If your property is worth $250,000 at the time of your passing, your heirs inherit it at that value. If they later sell it for $260,000, their taxable gain is only $10,000, not the $150,000 that accrued during your lifetime. This “step-up” is one of the most important yet least understood advantages in Estate Planning. Federal vs. Georgia Capital Gains 1. At the Federal Level The federal government taxes capital gains, that is, the profit you make when you sell an asset like a home or stock for more than what you paid. But not all gains are treated the same way: If you owned the asset for less than one year , the gain is considered ordinary income , taxed just like your salary. If you owned it for more than a year , it’s a long-term capital gain , which qualifies for a lower tax rate (0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on your income). Now, here’s where it gets interesting: when someone inherits a property, the law provides a step-up in basis . This means the property’s value is “reset” to its fair market value at the time it’s inherited. So if the heir sells the property shortly after, they’ll likely owe little or no federal capital gains tax , because the taxable gain, the difference between the inherited value and the sale price, is small. How Georgia Differs Here’s where things differ. Georgia doesn’t have a special “Capital Gains Tax.”Instead, it treats any capital gain as ordinary income under the state tax system, applying its standard income tax rate (up to about 5.49% ). That means that even if the federal step-up in basis reduces or eliminates federal tax liability, Georgia may still collect state income tax on any increase in value that happens between the time you inherit and the time you sell the property. What It Means for Estate Planning Coordinating your estate strategy involves considering both federal and state laws. While the step-up in basis is one of the most effective tools available to families, Georgia’s tax treatment can still affect how much your heirs ultimately retain. A well-structured plan ensures your estate benefits from the federal step-up while also minimizing any state-level exposure. Why This Matters Most families simply want to pass down what they’ve worked for without creating new financial stress for the next generation. But generous intentions can sometimes lead to unintended tax consequences. The good news is that with proper Estate Planning, these issues can be anticipated and managed. Timing matters, and so does understanding how different laws interact. Let’s Talk About Your Plan Estate and Tax Planning are deeply personal. Every family’s financial picture, values, and goals are unique.  If you’d like to understand how the step-up in basis or capital gains rules could affect your estate, the team at McGinn Law is ready to help, with the same clarity, care, and efficiency that define our approach to client service.
estate
by Terence McGinn 28 November 2025
Learn about probate administration to manage estate creditor claims in Georgia effectively. Secure your assets and plan ahead with guidance from McGinn Law.
Right Guardian for Your Kids
25 November 2025
Learn how estate planning protects your kids' future by selecting a dependable guardian with McGinn Law's guidance in Georgia. Secure their well-being today.